The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. Stable radial-velocity variations at the rotation period of AD Leonis: A test case study of current limitations to treating stellar activity

Kossakowski, D.; Kürster, M.; Henning, Th; Trifonov, T.; Caballero, J. A.; Lafarga, M.; Bauer, F. F.; Stock, S.; Kemmer, J.; Jeffers, S. V.; Amado, P. J.; Pérez-Torres, M.; Béjar, V. J. S.; Cortés-Contreras, M.; Ribas, I.; Reiners, A.; Quirrenbach, A.; Aceituno, J.; Baroch, D.; Cifuentes, C.; Dreizler, S.; Hatzes, A.; Kaminski, A.; Montes, D.; Morales, J. C.; Pavlov, A.; Pena, L.; Perdelwitz, V.; Reffert, S.; Revilla, D.; Lopez, C. Rodriguez; Rosich, A.; Sadegi, S.; Sanz-Forcada, J.; Schöfer, P.; Schweitzer, A.; Zechmeister, M.
Bibliographical reference

Astronomy and Astrophysics

Advertised on:
Number of authors
IAC number of authors
Refereed citations
Context. A challenge with radial-velocity (RV) data is disentangling the origin of signals either due to a planetary companion or to stellar activity. In fact, the existence of a planetary companion has been proposed, as well as contested, around the relatively bright, nearby M3.0 V star AD Leo at the same period as the stellar rotation of 2.23 days.
Aims: We further investigate the nature of this signal. We introduce new CARMENES optical and near-IR RV data and an analysis in combination with archival data taken by HIRES and HARPS, along with more recent data from HARPS-N, GIANO-B, and HPF. Additionally, we address the confusion concerning the binarity of AD Leo.
Methods: We consider possible correlations between the RVs and various stellar activity indicators accessible with CARMENES. We additionally applied models within a Bayesian framework to determine whether a Keplerian model, a red-noise quasi-periodic model using a Gaussian process, or a mixed model would explain the observed data best. We also exclusively focus on spectral lines potentially associated with stellar activity.
Results: The CARMENES RV data agree with the previously reported periodicity of 2.23 days, correlate with some activity indicators, and exhibit chromaticity. However, when considering the entire RV data set, we find that a mixed model composed of a stable and a variable component performs best. Moreover, when recomputing the RVs using only spectral lines insensitive to activity, there appears to be some residual power at the period of interest. We therefore conclude that it is not possible to determinedly prove that there is no planet orbiting in synchronization with the stellar rotation given our data, current tools, machinery, and knowledge of how stellar activity affects RVs. We do rule out planets more massive than 27 M⊕ (=0.084 MJup). Likewise, we exclude any binary companion around AD Leo with M sin i greater than 3-6 MJup on orbital periods <14 yr.

Tables A.2, A.3, A.4, A.5, and additional data (i.e., stellar activity indicators as shown in Figs. C.1, C.2, and C.3) are available at the CDS via anonymous ftp to ( or via
Related projects
Discovery of a system of super-Earths orbiting the star HD 176986 with about 5.7 and 9.2 Earth masses.
Very Low Mass Stars, Brown Dwarfs and Planets

Our goal is to study the processes that lead to the formation of low mass stars, brown dwarfs and planets and to characterize the physical properties of these objects in various evolutionary stages. Low mass stars and brown dwarfs are likely the most numerous type of objects in our Galaxy but due to their low intrinsic luminosity they are not so

Rebolo López
Projects' name image
Exoplanets and Astrobiology

The search for life in the universe has been driven by recent discoveries of planets around other stars (known as exoplanets), becoming one of the most active fields in modern astrophysics. The growing number of new exoplanets discovered in recent years and the recent advance on the study of their atmospheres are not only providing new valuable

Pallé Bago